Activities

 

The Quranic Perception of Difference

By Bashar Bakkour

MA in Islamic Studies

Lecturer at Al-Fatih Islamic Institute

First: Difference is a universal phenomenon

The Quran says: [If your Lord had willed, He would have made all mankind one single nation, but He willed it otherwise, and so they continue to differ.] [11:118] Elsewhere [And among His signs is the creations of the heavens and the earth, and the difference in your languages and colours] [30:22] Allah could have created us in the same form, with the same beliefs, ideas, customs, interests, etc…. However, this is not the nature of life.

Second: Freedom of belief in Islam

[ There shall be no compulsion in religion] [2: 256]

Islam sees faith as a matter of conviction. It never seeks converts by means of compulsion. Instead, it addresses the human mind, intellect and human commonsense. On the top of that, freedom of belief indicates freedom of expression and thought, without fear of potential threat and suppression. Otherwise, that freedom turns to be meaningless.

Third: Difference should lead to harmonious and amicable relationships, as well as constructive exchange.

[O people, We created you from male and female, and made you into nations and tribes, so that you may come to know each other.] [49:13]

Fourth: Targeting religious symbols is strictly prohibited

[And do not insult those whom they worship besides God, lest they insult God wrongfully without knowledge.] [ 6:108]

The dignity of difference as illustrated by the Prophet (PBUH)

1-The document which defines the status of the Jews and their relations with the Muslim State in Madīnah. It regards them as citizens within this state, they enjoy their religious freedom and state protection. On the other hand, they were requested to back Muslims against any potential enemy and never plot against them or threaten the security of the Muslim state.

2- In one of his sayings: "On the day of Resurrection I shall dispute with any one who oppresses a person from among the people of the Book, or violate his right, or puts a responsibility on him which is beyond his strength, or takes something from him against his will"

3-Once a funeral of Jewish person was passing the Prophet. As a sign of respect, he rose. When was asked about the reason, he replied: Is not he a human being?! (Authentic, recorded by Bukhari).

4-When the Prophet died, his armor was mortgaged to a Jew for little barely (Authentic, recorded by Bukhari).

"The Dignity of Difference" by Jonathon Sacks

Jonathon Sacks(a Chief Rabbi):" The word ' holy' in the Hebrew Bible Kadosh, actually means "different, distinctive, set apart"… As the great Rabbis observed some 1800 years ago, when a human being makes many coins in the same mint, they all come out the same. God makes every human being in the same mint, in the same image, His own, and yet we all come out differently. The religious challenge is to find God's image in someone who is not in our image, in someone whose colour is different, whose culture is different, who speaks a different language, tells a different story, and worships God in a different way "

The Myth of Clash of Civilizations

The above four Quranic principles, in particular the third one, are quite sufficient to prove the fallacy of this clash.

Samuel Huntington claims that civilizational differences will be primary source of regional and global conflicts.

In opposed to him, many have argued that 'clash of interests' rather than 'clash of civilizations' will continue to be real cause of conflict.